FA tutorial 3
Question 1
(a) What is distribution?
Answer
Distribution of profits to the shareholders is by means of declaring dividends. Usually only a portion of the profits will be distributed as dividends . Under normal circumstances, the only payment that the shareholders receive from the company is dividends. Dividends are profits of the company that is distributed to the shareholders as a return on their investment.
Dividends are paid in proportion to the nominal value of the share unless the articles of association of the company restrict them to the amount paid up on the shares. The most common form of dividend payment is cash dividend. Dividend can also be declared and paid in the form of shares , that is , bonus shares.
Dividend become payable only when it is declared. The articles of the company usually permit the directors to declare an interim dividend. Interim dividend is dividend declared and paid during the year whilst final dividend is the final dividend for the year and the amount is recommended by the directors to be approved by the shareholders at annual general meeting (AGM)
Section 365 of the companies Act 1965
The Act provides that companies may only make a distribution out of profits. So it is a form of restriction as to the profit available for distribution as dividends. However, the Act does not define profit available for distribution. Generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) limit the dividend distribution ( in cash ) to realized profits.
(b)
Explain whether the following items are realized or unrealized in nature:
i) Loss on sale of property
ii) Revaluation surplus arising from revaluation of a land and building
iii) Revaluation surplus relating to a property which has been sold
iv) Bad debts
v) Sales revenue
Answer
We realize the loss on sale of property immediately as we recognize the profit and loss immediately in our income statement
Revaluation surplus arising from revaluation of a land and building is unrealized because the land or building we still in use and we revalue it with the current market price which we could not get economic benefits until we sold our land or building int he end then it is realizable .
We are able to realized the transaction where the property is already been sold and we are able to see the result.
We are aware of bad debt which could not retrieve back in the future as we set of allowance for doubtful debt from our receivable for it , it is realizable
We are able to realize the sales revenue because it is the gain we receive from our sales .
(c)
What is a share premium ? Is it distributable in the form of dividend ?
Answer
Share premium , the difference between the issue price and the par value of share / The distribution is in the form of dividend in specie ( in kind ) , examples , bonus issue , known as non-cash dividend.
Question 2
(a)
What is revenue?
Revenue is the gross inflow of economic benefits during the period arising in the course of the ordinary activities of an entity when those inflows result in increase in equity , other than increases relating to contributions from equity participants.
(b)
State the recognition rules in relation to the following :
i) Sales of goods
ii) Rendering of services
iii) Interest, royalties and dividend
Answer
Rules for sales of goods as follows
- the seller transfers the significant risks and rewards of ownership to the buyer
- the seller does not retain management or control over the goods sold
- the amount of revenue can be measured reliably
- the transaction’s economic benefits will probably flow to the seller
- the cost incurred or to be incurred can be measured reliably.
Rules for rendering of services
- the revenue can be measured reliably
- the transaction’s economic benefits will probably flow to the provider
- the stage of completion at the balance sheet can be measured reliably
- the costs incurred or to be incurred can be measured reliably
Rules for interest , royalties and dividend when its probable and measureable
- interest is recognized on a time proportion basis
- royalties are accrued in accordance with the relevant contract
- dividends are recognized when the shareholders right to receive payment is established
Question 3
a)
Warisan Bhd enters into a franchise arrangement with Xam Bhd for the later to use and market its patented fried chicken products. The arrangement calls for payment of RM10million upfront to cover initial supply of equipment plus technical support and services for 5 years.
It is difficult to estimate precisely the value of technical support and services because Warisan Bhd products are unique and there is no market equivalent service prices of this nature. However , estimate of the cost to provide the technical support and service, based on the company similar franchise arrangement in the past , is about RM2million and it is considered that a 50% mark-up on cost is a reasonable profit of service.
Explain how the RM10million franchise fee should be recognized as revenue in the account of Warisan Bhd
Answer
The upfront franchise fees of RM10million covers the supply of the initial and subsequent supply of equipment and technical support or services for 5 years.
Accordingly , the fees are recognized as revenue on a basis that reflects the purpose for which the fees were charged.
In other words , revenue is recognized as the services are rendered . The amount of RM10million includes estimated price of continuing services of RM3m for 5 years.
Thus RM7million should be recognized as revenue immediately. The amount of RM3million is deferred and recognized over 5 years on straight line basis , Example , RM0.6million per year.
b)
MNO Bhd sold a stock item with a cost of RM50,000 to PQR Bhd on 1 January 2006 . The terms of the sale include a five yearly installments of RM15,000 each payable at the end of each year. The cash selling price of the stock is RM60,000.
Explain how the transaction above should be recognized in the accounts of MNO Bhd.
Answer
Revenue attributable to the sale price , exclusive of interest , is recognized at the date of sales ( RM60,000 at 1 January 2006 ) . The interest of RM15,000 is recognized as income as it is earned , on the time proportion basis , example , over 5 years , each year RM3000.
c)
Heritage Sdn Bhd deals in valuable paintings . On 1 January 2007 , it sold a piece of valuable painting to a customer for a nominal amount of RM12,100,000 payable on 1 January 2009 . Heritage Sdn Bhd’s current borrowing cost is 10% per annum.
Explain how the above transaction should be recognized in the accounts of Heritage Sdn Bhd.
Answer
Revenue from the sale of the painting to a customer is recognized presumably risks and rewards of ownership have passed to the customer since the customer is only required to settle the debt in 2 years time , the amount of RM12,100,000 should be discounted to its present value . Example , RM12,100,000/ 1.1^2 = RM 10,000,000
Therefore , the receivable is recorded at an amount of RM12,100,000 and interest income of RM2,100,000
Question 4
Given below are five situation that are independent of each other . The financial year end for all is 31 December 2008..
For each situation state :
a) Whether revenue can be recognized for the current year and if so , the amount that can be recognized ;
b) State the reasons why revenue can or cannot be recognized .
Scenario 1
Show-Time Sdn Bhd sold tickets for an opera to be staged at the Petronas Auditorium on 10 January 2009 . To date they collected RM10 million and incurred costs of RM 2 million .
Answer
The company should recognize RM 10 million admission fees in the following year . Although the tickets for the opera were sold in 2008 , the event would only be held in 2009 . Because no revenue in 2008 but cost already debit in prepayment and credit to expenses in the following year match with the revenue .
Scenario 2
Clockers Sdn Bhd sent branded watches to various shopping malls for display and sale . These shopping malls were to sell them at RM500 each and remit the proceeds (less15% commission charges) to Clockers Sdn Bhd. The shopping malls may return any unsold watches within 5 months of receiving them after which date they cannot return any unsold watches to Clockers Sdn Bhd . To date the shopping malls sell off the watches within 2 months . At the year-end 2000 of these watches were with the shopping malls .
Answer
Revenue us usually recognized when goods have been delivered . However , in this case , the watches are delivered on a “sale or return” basis . Example . returnable within 5 months.
Assuming the 2000 watches were sold within 2 months before the year end , revenue of RM1m (Gross amount) should be recognized for the current year .
Scenario 3
On 1 October 2008 Finances Bhd deposited RM20 million in fixed deposit for a 15 month period in a finance company . The interest rate is 10% p.a.
Answer
Earned 3/12 x RM20m x 10% = RM 0.5m
According to FRS 118 , interest income should be recognized on time proportion basis . For the year ended 31 December 2008 , the company has earned interest income for 3 months , the amount of which is RM 0.5m
Scenario 4
Kontracktor Bhd ( a non-exempt enterprise ) commenced building a shopping mall for a customer on 1 April 2008 and expected to take 15 months to complete it . The fixed contract price was RM25 million and the estimated total costs to complete was RM20 million . Costs incurred to date was RM8 million and the customer was billed RM7 million.
Answer
When outcome of the construction contract , example to build a shopping mall can be estimated reliably , revenue should be recognized by reference to the stage of completion at the balance sheet date .
The stage of completion is 40% using the cost basis (40% x 20m = 8m)
Contract revenue recognized for the year ended 31 December 2008 is 40% x 25m = 10m
Sales 10m = 40% x 25m
Cost 8m = 40% x 20m
5m
Scenario 5
Timber Sdn Bhd sold timber costing RM10 million to Sawmill Sdb Bhd on 1 December 2008 with an understanding that Timber Sdn Bhd will buy the stock back in 6 months time for RM12 million.
Answer
The terms of the agreement should be analyzed to determined whether is a sale transaction or not .
If Sawmill has significant risks/rewards of the ownership of timber , sales transaction ( recognized revenue by Timber )
If timber retains risks/rewards , financing arrangement ( Timber as asset / amount as liabilities )